The retention of our Australian was mostly put on hold while we were in Germany, in favour of them spending more time leanring and speaking German. Besides, there wasn't much competition between the two, being so different. Living in a culture with a different dialect, on the other hand, is much more subtle. Most of the 'replacement words' -- 'vacation' for 'holiday', 'parking lot' for 'car park' -- are generally already known and very easy to understand even if they've never been heard before. Remembering to use them in context when speaking to an American is a bit harder. Americans are less likely to have heard the other version than we are to have heard theirs.
A couple of our children are picking up a few accented words. Bryna has a few and Elijah tends to adapt his accent to his audience. It's most obvious talking with him immediately after picking him following time with his friends. At first, we'd remind him but I'm pretty sure he's not doing it consciously, so now I just let it go.
Watching Australian television shows wasn't something we could do in Germany -- everything is overdubbed there -- but the children have a few they watch religiously here. H
And so to German. To be honest, my German has never been that great. I figured out enough to hold a grammatically poor conversation for about 20 minutes. I can read a bit and know plenty of less used words that the rest of the family didn't need to know, like Rechtschutzversicherung (legal insurance) and Ölwannedichtung (oil sump gasket). Gaynor and the children on the other hand did wonderfully. Gaynor could teach a 45 minute lesson at church and each child was passing German as a subject at their school. In the case of Joshua, Elijah and Mara that was at the academic high school. Ariana spoke fluently and without an accent with all her friends and Bryna really only spoke German.
Gaynor and I have spoken a number of times about steps we'd take to help the children retain their fluency in German. Unfortunately for Bryna her only chance was for us to mostly speak German at home and that is something very hard to do when it's your non-native tongue. Bryna now only remembers a few German words and phrases and almost always speaks in English. Her transition was complete within the first six months of our arrival. The retention improves with the older children and Joshua, Elijah and Mara seem to recall virtually all of theirs with Ariana somewhere in between.
However, we are of the firm opinion that without constant practice and opportunities to use it they'd lose it. So to that end, we've tried to bring as many German books and DVDs with us as possible and we've recently had an influx of books and DVDs when one of Elijah's old school mates came to visit for a few weeks. We also have an incentive scheme for them to read and report on German books, we subscribe to a monthly church-related magazine in German, a friend in Germany sends us copies of one of the children's favourite television programs Die Pfefferkörner (English description) and every Wednesday is supposed to be 'Deutschsprechtag' -- 'German speaking day'. I say 'supposed to be' because not everyone remembers for all of the day but we are mostly making an effort! Hopefully these opportunities and ideas will be enough to help them retain the lion's share of their ability.
And finally, speaking of languages, we've set the children the challenge of being fluent in three languages by their eighteenth birthday. Some have picked French and others Spanish but we'll see how they go. By the way, we've been pleased to see that southern California, at least, is very bilingual. Of course there are many people who are native or fluent Spanish speakers but there are also many stores that have signs in both languages. Perhaps 'American' as a synonym for 'monolingual' is on the way out -- much to the chagrin of some US citizens I'm sure.
Good luck! I'm barracking for the lot of you. The more languages, the better, hey?
ReplyDeleteSeriously, though, is the whole monolingual American thing just a stereotype? Cos, where I grew up, everything (including government stuff like driving tests and election forms) was in English and Spanish. Everyone knew how to speak at least some Spanish and understood even more.
Beyond that, in our home my dad spoke Czech and some Russian, my eldest brother spoke German and (post mission) Japanese, and my other brother and sisters all spoke Spanish. Maybe it depends on which part of the country...?
Maybe a lot of it does have to do with where you grew up but also with whom you have grown up. Your family may not be typical just as our family may not be either. Hard to say. It may also just be perception. I've been pleasantly surprised finding people who speak more than one language but it doesn't usually come out without enquiry. I think in Europe there were many more opportunities to use more than one language.
ReplyDeleteYou raise a good point. Perhaps the American lingual stereotype is a couple of decades out of date now?
And I'm with you: the more languages the better!
I like the German Thursday idea!
ReplyDeleteBryna will probably have German hidden away somewhere just as the English came to the fore in the US
I have found online chat with facebook with my cousins, aunts and uncles in Chile has helped sharpen my written Spanish and got me thinking on the fly. Also a great way to get to know the relatives I have not met in person.
ReplyDeleteYou guys should have Spanish Saturday too!!
Cheers
Bruce
do not worry for that Fenton, as a colombian guy, I suffered the same in Spain with my latinamerican spanish
ReplyDeleteHasta pronto
Óscar